Antique Clock Movements versus Modern clock movements,
- or -
Why it may be better to replace rather than overhaul the modern German clock  movement.

Modern clocks have mass produced movements, usually from Germany.  The synthetic oils used in these are quite good.  If your clock is in a low dust area, and the movement looks clean,  in home cleaning and oiling every five to ten years is reasonable.  These modern mass produced movements are quite good, but the furniture stores that sell clocks rarely explain that 20 to 30 years is the expected life of these movements.  When the pivots and the holes they run in wear, these movements tend to tighten up and bind or jam.  When examining one of these movements, I look for worn pivots, wear on the bushings or holes the pivots rotate in, and worn gears.  An expensive movement that needs some bushing and pivot work is a good candidate for overhaul.  In some cases however, a new movement can be installed at a cost that is competitive with repairing the existing movement.  New movements typically have a two year warranty and are completely new and unworn - ready for another 20 to 30 years of enjoyment.

If replacing rather than repairing your existing movement is a reasonable alternative, I will tell you so you can make an informed decision.

Antique clocks, particularly grandfather clocks, were built with thick cast and hammered brass plates, large gears, and large pivots.  The mechanical layout tends to open up clearances with wear, unlike modern mass produced movements.  Some of these clocks will run for a long time with incredible amounts of wear.  If you have an antique clock that runs on after the hour strike, or that runs "oddly", please stop the clock and call a clock maker.  These beautiful old clocks need a bit of care, and while any clock can be repaired, catching a problem early can save a large expense.  Antique clocks should receive regular dusting.  In home cleaning, oiling, inspection, and adjustment every three to five years is a reasonable compromise period in a fairly dust free home.  A complete disassembly and overhaul every 20 years is usually a safe interval.  Some movements may not need service this often, others may need it far more often.  Frayed cables should be replaced promptly.  Many old clocks have split or missing panels in the base from weights dropping.  Please don't let this happen to your clock!

Replacing a movement in an antique clock is almost NEVER the correct thing to do!

Return to home page